Ulnar Wrist Pain
The ulna is the smaller of the two bones of the forearm. it's on the same side of the forearm as the small finger. Pain on the ulnar side of the wrist is a relatively common problem in adults but not children. Seen most commonly in men in their late twenties to forties, it is especially common after a fall on an outstretched hand with or without an associated broken bone. Taking a careful history, performing a thorough examination, and providing treatment skillfully results in cure or improvement in the majority of cases. Advances in arthroscopic surgical technique and wrist research performed in the past decade are credited with the good results now obtainable. Derangement in the wrist often causes pain, weakness of grip and pinch strength, it may affect one's sleep, and overall, results in a loss of productivity.
The wrist, or carpus, is composed of eight bones working together as one unit, plus the ends of the two forearm bones - the radius and the ulna. Wrist motion occurs in four directions: up (dorsal), down (palmer), or side-to-side (radial and ulnar). The radial half of the wrist is predominantly supplied with sensibility from the median, superficial radial, and posterior interosseous nerves while the ulnar side of the wrist is usually innervated from the ulnar nerve. Thus, entrapment of the ulnar nerve at the wrist, or more commonly at the elbow, may result in ulnar wrist or ulnar hand pain and/or burning, numbness, aching and decreased tolerance for writing or other manual activities.
Differential Diagnoses & Causes
1) Ulnar Tunnel Syndrome
|Pressure on the ulnar nerve
causing the muscle to spasm.
No pressure on the ulnar nerve.
Symptoms of numbness and burning, clumsiness, and pain in the ulnar side (small finger side) of the hand usually occur at the same time as the symptoms on the opposite side of the hand; i.e. the same time as a person with carpal tunnel syndrome. To a large extent, it is a moot point except when it comes to excluding ulnar nerve entrapment at the cubital tunnel. This is because carpal tunnel release simultaneously decompresses the ulnar nerve in Guyon's canal. Guyon's canal ( the ulnar tunnel) is directly adjacent to the carpal tunnel separated by a septum.
As far as I can discern, the relief of the symptoms occurs much like the relief experienced by a person sitting in the front seat of a bench-type car seat when extra occupants beyond the normal two leave; i.e. when three or four are sitting on the seat designed for two passengers, there is much more space available for the remaining passengers when the couple of those squeezed in are allowed to leave. When we open up the carpal tunnel, we are widening it. According to research done on CT and MRI scans, we are increasing the size of the carpal tunnel about 25% and eliminating the pressure. It is extremely uncommon to have to perform isolated ulnar tunnel decompression; i.e. ulnar tunnel syndrome as an isolated entity does not occur very often and when it does, we need to be wary of a possible ganglion in the canal. It is also unnecessary to separately open up the ulnar tunnel at the time of carpal tunnel release surgery. This has been well established in the medical literature. Richman and Gelberman* in 1989 on the basis of what appeared to be quite limited study concluded that ulnar nerve decompression at the time of carpal tunnel release occurred because of the change in the shape of Guyon's canal with the decompression; i.e. it changed from a trapezoid to more of an oval, providing relief.
I have seen many MRI scans of patients pre- and post carpal tunnel release for other reason, and I have yet to see a configuration similar to that which they published in their article. I do not believe that their specific interpretation (change in shape from a trapezoid to an oval) is as likely as the one I have indicated above.
|Improper Sleep Posture|
2) Cubital Tunnel Syndrome
Cubital tunnel syndrome, or entrapment of the ulnar nerve at the elbow, occurs in about three women for every man. Usually patients are over age 30. It also tends to occur in a person who habitually sleeps with their elbows flexed (bent).
3) Torn Triangular Fibrocartilage (TFCC)
A torn TFCC is diagnosed by local TFCC tenderness on the top of the wrist. Ulnar wrist pain tends to worsen with movement of the hand to the direction of the ulna (ulnar deviation), gripping, twisting and pounding often causes increased symptoms. Confirmation is with a positive arthrogram or direct visualization during arthroscopy (most accurate). MRI scanning may possibly show a torn TFCC but we have less experience with MRI and it is a more expensive test. Swelling indicates synovitis - engorgement of the joint or tendon lining.
|Outcome of Surgery for Torn TFCC|
|Arthroscopic Trimming||Melone 1991||83% Good/Excellent|
|Osterman 1990||88% Good/Excellent|
|Ulnar Shortening||Melone 1998||92% Good/Excellent|
|Hulsizer 1997||91% Excellent|
Kienbock's is a term applied to painful loss of blood supply (bone infarct) occurring in the lunate of the wrist. There is no good explanation why it occurs. Fortunately it is relatively rare. Though there are numerous treatment options, overall satisfaction is about 70%, i.e. there is room for improvement. Unloading of the lunate and/or reestablishing blood flow by insertion of an artery or a bone block with an artery attached are the main options in early disease before the lunate crumbles. After bone crumbles then salvage procedures such as PRC or fusion are available.
|Bone appears more
solid due to loss of
blood flow causing
it to die and crumble.
5) Ulno-Carpal Abutment
Ulno-carpal abutment causes pain from impact of the prominent ulna on the wrist bones. It results from incorrect healing of a wrist fracture in which the ulna is left longer (relative to the radius) than it had been before the injury. Degenerative growth disturbance may also cause this. Thus the prominent ulna also crushes the TFCC.
|Bone of shortened
ulna visible through
hole in TFCC.
6) Ulnar Artery Thrombosis (Hypothenar Hammer Syndrome)
Ulnar artery clotting occurs predominantly in heavy smokers, over age 50, that also do a lot of pounding with their hands. These patients usually present with finger tip lesions.
|Ulnar artery clotting causing lesions on the fingertips.|
A ganglion is a small fluid-filled degenerative sac protruding from a joint or tendon sheath; these occur frequently on the wrist. They occasionally cause pain. Surgical removal is the treatment of choice though about 15% will recur.
8) Piso-Triquetral Arthritis
9) Extensor Carpi Ulnaris Tendinosis
10) Carpal Instability
11) Lunatotriquetral Instability
Treatment is directed by localization of the site of maximal tenderness, review of x-rays and MRI scanning (when indicated to rule out avascular necrosis). MRI scan, or arthrography (dye injection study) may also be used to rule out a torn ligament, though arthroscopy is more sensitive and accurate. Depending upon whether the problem is degenerative (Cortisone injection or NSAID), traumatic (repair or trimming of TFCC), or nerve entrapment (cubital or ulnar tunnel release), will determine the treatment needs of each patient.
Most tears require trimming of the TFCC. This can be done utilizing outpatient arthroscopic technique, wherein several small puncture wounds are made in the wrist, through which a fiberoptic scope and tools are inserted into the distracted wrist. Occasionally a torn TFCC is amenable to arthroscopic suture repair. This is a major advance from the past. Arthroscopic wrist surgery is something with which Dr. Ichtertz has over ten years experience.
Usually treatment for abutment syndrome involves shortening of the ulna bone. This is done by taking a small wedge of bone out of the ulna and stabilizing the bone with a metal plate and screws until healed. Because of the secure fixation with the screws and plate, one usually does not have to wear a cast during the healing process which requires 8-12 weeks.
Limited carpal fusion involves binding two or more of the eight wrist bones together in order to eliminate pain-causing motion. This may be the treatment of choice for degenerative arthritis or instability within the wrist.
Proximal row carpectomy (PRC) involves bone removal while allowing retention of motion. This is used ever more frequently due to good results, rather than a more elaborate procedure.
Risks of Surgery
Most wrist operations cause little pain and all are performed on an outpatient basis. Every operation has inherent risks: a remote risk of infection, nerve injury, and new or incresaed pain are possibilities. An attempt at wrist fusion may result in non-union, i.e. non-healing, especially in smokers, thus may require a second operation in a rare case. Of course with any operation there are some people who develop prominent scars. This occurs more often and is more noticeable in people with a dark complexion.
Though ulnar-sided wrist pain is often difficult to diagnose and difficult to treat, Dr. Ichtertz is usually able to arrive at an accurate diagnosis leading to a predictable outcome from treatment. Where feasible, an attempt is made to solve problems non-operatively with anti-inflammatory and analgesic medication, splinting and injection. Physical therapy rarely solves pain problems related to the hand or wrist. Taking time off of work/disability is not considered to be part of the treatment and has never been proven to be particularly beneficial in and of itself. An attempt will always be made to keep a person productive by allowing maximal use of the hand whenever possible.
*Richman JA, Gelberman RH, Rydevik BL et al. Carpal tunnel syndrome: morphologic changes after release of transverse carpal ligament. J Hand Surg 1989; 14A: 852-7.